Explore the Godfather's Pizza Express - Fortville menu featuring signature pizzas like Humble Pie and Chicken Bacon Ranch, plus create-your-own options. Enjoy top-rated, carryout-only Italian-style pizza with fresh ingredients at 322 E Broadway St, Fortville, IN.
Godfather's Pizza Express in Fortville offers a compelling slice of pizza tradition, right in the heart of Hancock County. Located at 322 E Broadway St, this spot is an express outlet that promises the same great taste Godfather's has been known for since 1977. The menu is straightforward yet satisfying, anchored by their signature sauces and fresh mozzarella, which bring an authentic Italian-American flair to every bite.
The "Create Your Own" pizza options stand out for their flexibility and value. Starting with a large cheese pizza at $11.99, customers can easily customize with one or two toppings, priced at $13.99 and $15.99 respectively. This makes it easy to build a pizza that matches your cravings—whether you favor classic pepperoni, savory Italian sausage, or fresh vegetables.
The mini pizza selection is a highlight, perfect for anyone seeking smaller portions without sacrificing flavor. The "All Meat Combo" packs an intense punch with ham, pepperoni, bacon, beef, Italian sausage, and sausage atop the signature sauce and mozzarella—ideal for meat lovers. Veggie fans will appreciate the "Veggie" mini with black olives, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and tomatoes. Meanwhile, the "Spicy Hawaiian" adds a daring twist with jalapeños paired alongside ham, pineapple, and bacon bits, creating a spicy-sweet balance that’s both unique and addictive.
Dessert streusels round out the experience, offering a satisfying end to any meal with their delicious dessert pizzas. This adds a homey, bakery feel that sets Godfather's apart from typical fast-food pizzerias.
Customer reviews underscore the consistent quality and nostalgic appeal of Godfather’s Pizza Express. Sam Torres praises the perfectly seasoned, tangy sauce and non-oily dough—a testament to the brand’s dedication to craft. John Kessler highlights it as a Hancock County gem, suitable for a quick meal or a snack stop. While some mention the lack of dine-in options or slight differences in pizza thickness compared to older experiences, they still affirm the robust flavors and quality ingredients that make this place a local favorite.
From its strategic express format to its focused menu, Godfather's Pizza Express - Fortville encapsulates the essence of comfort pizza with a contemporary, convenient twist. Whether stopping by for a quick lunch or ordering carryout for dinner, the blend of rich, well-seasoned sauce, fresh toppings, and crispy crust leaves a memorable impression. It’s pizza made with care, echoing decades of tradition yet perfectly suited for today’s busy lifestyles.
